HomeMy WebLinkAboutItem #1 Urban Renewal District Funds/6470-t-\
CHUBBUCK
1 0 0 H 0
Memo
To: Honorable Mayor and City Council
From: Bridger Morrison, Public Works Director
Date: January 9, 2024
Re: Funding Request for Public Works
Public Works Department
290 E. Linden Ave., Chubbuck, ID 83202
208.237.2430 — Fax 208.237.2409
www.CityofChubbuck.us
As a follow up to our discussion last week about the additional needs in Public Works and as requested
by Council Member Evans, I'd like to share a brief description of our priorities. As discussed in my
presentation, the biggest needs in the Public Works Department are in the Street Department. My
presentation discussed additional funding needs for pavement maintenance, equipment, and projects.
Although I believe all of the needs are important and funding any of them would provide significant
benefit to the city, it is my recommendation that as much additional funding as possible be dedicated to
the Street Department to be spent on pavement maintenance. We are already deficient in this area and
the reduction in CDA funding will only make it more difficult in the future. As we've discussed in the
past, delayed maintenance of pavement today will result in exponentially higher costs in the future. For
that reason, I believe the best return on any additional funding would result from applying it to
pavement maintenance.
I believe that we can delay the purchase of some equipment and look for other ways to fund the other
equipment needs within the existing budget. As for the projects, there may be a need to revisit this topic
in the future but there is not an immediate need and we will continue to look for grants and other
funding opportunities.
We understand that the needs in all city departments will always exceed our funding ability and we may
not be able to reach our funding goals in the Street Department. However, we will continue to be as
efficient and proactive as possible and I believe we have the information and tools to make the most out
of what funding we do have. Thank you for your consideration.
J:lAdministration�Director�Memos to Council�Additional Funding Memo to Council1-9-24.docx
440d,t\
CHUBBUCK
1 0 0 H 0
Memo
To: Honorable Mayor & City Council
Community Services Department
290 E Linden Ave., Chubbuck, ID 83202
208.237.2430
From: Devin Hillam, Community Services Director ID 1
Date: January30, 2024
www.CityofChubbuck.us
Re: Community Services' funding needs with expired TIF district funds
As previously discussed, the funding needs of the Parks and Recreation Division of Community Services is
in dire need of system -wide maintenance. Total estimated cost for these prioritized improvements is $291,654 not
including an estimate for #5 that we're still awaiting. Safety issues, legal liabilities, and efficiencies are driving our
funding request and with the good weather my team has now had the ability to assess pathways and the parks
system and we have cost estimates. Please see note #6 about other park needs not estimated as part of this
correspondence.
1. Priority #1: Playground Resurfacing
10 parks need existing playground surfacing (compact gravel) replaced with materials which
will meet national safety standards (depth of material is based upon fall height and radius from
improvements. Materials were quoted from a trusted playground installer but have not been
formally bid. Replacement material is proposed as engineered wood fiber (the same material
that was just installed at our 2 new parks at Hiram and Long parks).
i. Those parks are: Armstrong (est. $17,500), Bistline ($12,000), Briarwood ($17,500), Espie
($15,500), Heritage ($17,500), Jerry Rowland ($12,000), Mary Harker ($15,500), Mary's
($15,500), Heartland ($12,000), Tree Valley/Community ($15,500).
ii. Total cost: $150,500 (mobilization and contingency built in).
2. Priority #2: Side -by -Side
The division currently uses aged ATVs to perform functions like weed spraying, snowplowing,
and other maintenance. A UTV would replace an aged ATV and allow for more rapid spraying
of weeds and performing of functions- rather than stopping at every week to spray and resume,
a side-by-side will enable a team to quicky address weeds while one drives and the other sprays.
As the City as taken on more landscaped streets, roundabouts, and wide paths (existing at New
Day, planned for along canal between Hawthorne and Philbin), the need for efficiencies has
increased as we with resources given for the number of parks staff. Estimated cost is $40,000.
3. Priority #3: Pathway Restoration
Capell, Cotant, Mary's, Bicentennial, and Heritage parks need some level of pathway restoration,
be it seal coating or in some cases, adding overlay materials. Upon review and based on
discussions with multiple contractors, the estimated cost to sealcoat the pathways (and where
needed to do some overlay and crack sealing and section replacement) is approximately
J:\Administration\00 Community Services Dept Admin\Memos to Council\1.30.24 Funding Requests_parks FY24
TIF monies.docx 1
$50,000. With a 20% contingency for site mobilization and other costs, the estimated total is
$60,000.
4. Priority #4: ADA Pathway Connectivity
a. There are 14 parks that have accessibility connectivity issues related to accessing playgrounds,
pavilions, and courts.
i. Those parks are:
1. Jerry Rowland
a. Needs path to playground and basketball court.
b. Estimated cost is $2,000 + $500 ADA ramp
2. Community/Tree Valley
a. Needs path to playground and basketball court.
b. Estimated cost is $2,000 + $500 ADA ramp
3. Hartland
a. Needs path to playground, basketball court, and pavilion.
b. Estimated cost is $2,500 + $500 ADA ramp
4. Mary's
a. Needs path to pickleball court and rebuild ADA ramps
b. Estimated cost is $3,500
5. Briarwood
a. Needs pathway to playground
b. Estimated cost (can be used with PW project for cost savings)- $1,500
+ $500 ADA ramp
6. Sample
a. Needs path to playground
b. Estimated cost is $1,000+ $500 ADA ramp
7. Dalton
a. Needs path to playground
b. Estimated cost is $1,000+ $500 ADA ramp
8. Cotant
a. Needs path to east court
b. Estimated cost is $1,000
9. Chase Park
a. Needs path to playground
b. Estimated cost is $3,450+ $500 ADA ramp
10. Larry Miller Park
a. Needs path to playground and basketball court
b. Estimated cost is $2,000+ $500 ADA ramp
11. Park Meadows
a. Need paths to pavilions
b. Estimated cost is $1,000
12. Armstrong
a. Needs path to playground, basketball court, and pavilion
b. Estimated cost is $3,000+ $500 ADA ramp
13. Mark Harker
a. Need path to playground and basketball court
b. Estimated cost is $2,845+ $500 ADA ramp
14. Heritage Park
J:\Administration\00 Community Services Dept Admin\Memos to Council\1.30.24 Funding Requests_parks FY24
TIF monies.docx 2
a. Need path to playground and basketball court
b. Estimated cost is $2,000+ $500 ADA ramp
b. Total ADA estimated cost: $34,295
c. Total cost with 20% contingency (likely a high mobilization cost): $41,154
5. Priority #5: Repair infield and outfield areas on baseball and softball fields to level grass and
infield dirt.
a. Currently awaiting an estimate.
6. Other needs: There are many other needs throughout the parks system that include replacing aged tot
lot equipment, renovating pavilions, repairing concrete/asphalt pads, resurfacing the pickleball court at
Mary's Park, repairing basketball courts, replacing the Cotant Park backstops, renovating the Cotant
Park restrooms, lighting at fields, etc. Although estimates are not provided for those costs, I want to
make the Council aware that the parks system's needs are many and the longer we prolong
maintenance, the greater the costs of repair/replacement will be. We will continue to develop a detailed
capital improvement plan and to seek outside funding opportunities.
J:\Administration\00 Community Services Dept Admin\Memos to Council\1.30.24 Funding Requests_parks FY24
TIF monies.docx 3
za�;
CHUBBUCK
1 0 N H 0
City of Chubbuck
Council Study Session Minutes
January 3, 2024
4:00 PM
City Hall Council Chambers
290 East Linden, Chubbuck, ID 83202
CALL TO ORDER: Mayor England
COUNCIL PRESENT: Melanie Evans, Roger Hernandez, Nonnan Reece, and Dan Heiner.
STAFF MEMBERS PRESENT: Mayor Kevin England, City Attorney Ryan Lewis, Public Works
Director Bridger Morrison, Public Works Operations Manager Rami Smoot, Community
Services Director Devin Hillam, Parks Manager Aaron Schilhabel, Development Services
Manager Sean Harris, Police Chief Nick Sasser, Senior Crime Scene Investigator and Ordinance
Enforcement Officer Aaron Harker, Fire Chief Merlin Miller, Human Resource Director Scott
Gummersall, City Treasurer Rich Morgan, and City Clerk Joey Bowers.
GENERAL BUSINESS:
1. Discussion on the possible disposal of approximately 0.08 acres of City property Iocated
at the intersection of Adams Street & Mesquite Drive.
Community Services Director Devin Hillam presented the disposal of approximately
0.08 acres of City property located at the intersection of Adams Street & Mesquite Drive.
Currently landscaped with grass and bushes that require parks & rec maintenance. No
beneficial public use of the small park. No recreational amenities.
2. Discussion on Funds from the Chubbuck Development Authority Expired 1992 Urban
Renewal District, and the possibility of reopening the FY24 budget.
City Treasurer Rich Morgan presented that the City had received 463,025 from the
County for monies from the Chubbuck Development Authority expired 1992 Urban
Renewal District. Mr. Morgan stated that the Council could reopen the FY24 budget to
include these monies with specifications, or save it for future budget discussions.
Community Services Director Devin Hillam presented that the Parks Department
could use all of these funds for backlog in park improvement maintenance projects, ADA
issues, safety concerns, and pathway improvements.
Police Chief Nick Sasser stated that the Police Department could use $46,927 of the
available funds as part of this year's FY24 budget. Chief Sasser presented an opportunity
for the Chubbuck Police to have two officers join Pocatello's Special Response Team.
This opportunity would allow these two officers to receive quality Immediate Response
Unit (IRU) training from a local police department with an established team, and access
to an entire IRU Team without having to just rely on a Mutual Aid Agreement with
surrounding agencies. Chief Sasser also stated that his number one priority is the health
and safety of his crew, and he would like to sign up for a Mindbase Platform to improve
and address the wellness and vitality within the department. The Police Department is
also in need of some training mats for their new training room.
Senior Crime Scene Investigator and Ordinance Enforcement Officer Aaron Harker
presented that the Evidence Division really needed to replace an evidence drying cabinet
as an essential safety tool for their department. The current drying cabinet was an old
cabinet that belong to Bannock County and had stopped working after it was moved
during the remodel and could no longer be repaired. The replacement cost for this cabinet
was $15,849.
Public Works Director Bridger Morrison presented that the Public Works Department
could use all of these funds to go towards pavement maintenance, and equipment needs.
To maintain the City's overall pavement condition index (PCI), an estimated $1.1 million
per year is needed for asphalt maintenance. The Public Works Department could also use
these funds to go towards the Hawthorne Road Bridge, or as the City's required match for
the Idaho Transportation Departments (ITD) Yellowstone/ Siphon Rd. intersection
project.
ADJOURN: Mayor Kevin England adjourned at 5:19.
Jo rty Clerk
evin Engl L,ayor
FY'24 REQUEST- PARKS & REC
• There is an approx. 0"400$800,000 backlog in park improvement
maintenance projects
• Toy replacement
• Bathroom updates
• Field renovations
o Walking Path/Basketball Court resealing/replacing portions
o Parking lot resurfacing
o Dri
• Not to mention, the existing maintenance backlog does not include
nking Fountain replacement
funding needs for future Miller and Truman/Espie Parks.
Armstrong Park
Bicentennial Park
jA 11
41
nit
low
Aimm
Bicentennial Park
AVY
' _ �. �, ! .w, ,: •� � / I r ._ �....�. _ � v.. it -z.,. �
x _d,now
t
} ,,, f '
Q 00 0% EMS ANA A rI% MI/
:TT71 ■ &Fo
s
.3�"° y `+irk .£k`�•+ s 4 6 � *.
Cotant Park
k-
iK46
Cotant Park
MI
44L�lm
r
Amok ANw ■Alk A. nw ■��i
A
a,
a9FWA mm FOR 7�A &Fw
e��
Mary's/Heartland Parks
Mary's/Heartland Parks
.. u,--�.... a. ��:r^-.. S .-., ..... 's'!":. �.. ,- ,.,'.' , ^rf_.'^v'F-.:-"SYR:s`,::•iir '4, ..,.. -
rx.
R � S
Awmg-
�.. r
Community Park (Garden Dr
r
U-
CHUBBUCK
!�OkAmoll] 7.7SJ:
Park- Maintenance
FY23 Approved 'STD ActuaI
Mowing
Restroom
-
291.00
Irrigation
25,000.00
7,500.00
11249.00
weeds
1,500.00
51200.00
-
Trees
Light Poles
6,000.00
650.00
Fertilizer
1,000.00
2,000.00
-
3'965.00
500.00
20, 7 00.00
$ 2' 110.00
5Park- Facility Maintenance FY23Approved
Playgrounds
125,000 ;--0
-
Restroom
1,964.00
9,000.00'
Building
25,000.00
1,500.00
Walking Path
947.00
1,500.00
Pavilion
91500.00
1,000.00
Light Poles
1,000.00
BasketbaII Court
1,000.00
-
Fence
3'965.00
500.00
Splash Pad
12,500.00
Volleyball Court
1,000.00
Ball Fields
2,500.00
Tennis Courts
60,000.00
,5CID. 00
YTD Actu a
125,000 ;--0
2°919.00
50,000
1,964.00
51000.00
6,152.00
25,000.00
109.00
5,000.00
947.00
11000.00
91500.00
199.00
500 O s
125 0 C s
665.00
1,000.00
3'965.00
19, 144.00
0
FY24Proposed Justification
201000.00 Contrading vMere make financial sense
7,500.00
51200.00
61000.00
21000.00
40,700.00
FY24Proposed Justification
125,000 ;--0
Replace/repair outdated and-,�;orn out equ ipt a I I over city}
50,000
Remodel outdated restrooms forbetter,,�inter'izat'ion
51000.00
25,000.00
Paths need sealed, patched, or portions removed/rep laced
5,000.00
Dav i I ions need painted and bird proofed
11000.00
91500.00
UtDclate backboards, nets, cracks, etc
500 O s
125 0 C s
1,000.00
80,000 s lackstop renovation, field renovation' bleachers I II
90,000.00 60k carried over from FY29 into F#24, 90k from fund balance from parks capital planning
$ 401,900.00
Park- Shoulder Work F'Y23 Approved YTD ActuaI FY24 Proposed Justification
Snag Removal x,900.00 S 365,0O $ 1,500.00
S Park- Property
FY23 Approved
Trash 9,500.00
a _.500.00
5,000.00
YTD ActuaI FY24Proposed Justification
- 9,500 �L
- _.500.00
S - 51000.00
CHUBBUCK
1 0 A H o
0
S Farb- Shoulder Work
FY23 Approved
YTI)
ACtUa I
FY24 Proposed Justification
Snow Remova
7,500.00
S
366.00
S 1x500.00
FY2 3 Approved
Trash 3x50: 00
ADA 1.5CIL", 00
SeO00.00
YTD Actu a
Park- Ad-ditiona I Services FY2 3 Ap p rove d VTD Ac tea a I
Hanging Flo er s q�OOC).C)O $ -
FY24 Proposed Justification
3,500.00
1:500 CO
5,000.00
FY24 P ro p o s e d! U s t-ificati on
gr000.00
FY'24 REQUEST- PARKS & REC
• Side by Side w/ attachments (weed spraying, snow removal,
fertilizing) - $40,000
• Trim Mower- $17,000
• Commercial mower- $90,000
• $60k was budgeted for Osborn Tennis Cou
capacity to advertise the job t
more year. Anticipated cost FY24)0
rt resurfacing in '23. No
his year and court holding up for 1
$90k (carry over FY23, add $20k for
CHUBBUCK
5 Park- Additional Services
=uel & Lubricants
SmaII Tool/Equipment
Large Equipment
FY23 Approved
13,500.00
3,500.00
10,000.00
27,x.{0
!�MkAmoll] 7.7SJ:
YTD Ac to a
9,576.00
664.00
4,581.00
14, X21.00
0
FY24Proposed Justification
13,500.00
3,500.00
147..000.00 $107k from Fund Balance for Mokever and Trimmer Mower; $40k for side-hy-side ,,�gith attachments
1&4,x.00
CHUBBUCK
1 0 A H o
CS Pa rk- Safety
Training
Clothing
Equipment
Testi rig
'i Total (Parks,)
FY2 3 Ap p rove d
4,000.00
2,000.00
600.00
500.00
7Fx00.00
C?
0
19
YTD Attu a I
1:185.00
96.00
4,063.00
65.00
G' 2RO. 00
FY24Proposed
3,000.00
2,000.00
600.00
500.00
Gr 100.00
. 1 316p 7 7 2.00 I' 341p 7 00.00
. _... _� Budget
� +$571,700 vs FY23
■ X87,200 are personnel (inflationary adjust; insurance)
FY'24 REQUEST- SUMMARY
■ $484,500 are:
• From 1992 Plan $
o Increases to lines t
o match actuals
• Contracting services when better deal than city can
o Facility Backlog Maintenance
o Dept side-by-side for more efficiency
• From Fund Balance
o $60k carryover from FY23 budget for tennis courts
o $107k from fund balance from parks capital planning-
mower/trimmer
Urban Renewal District
(request for additional project funding)
1) Special Response Team
2) Officer Wellness
3) Evidence Drying Cabinet
• Aaron Harker
�o �
PF
Special Response Team (SRT)
w
�e Chief Guiberson
1. That we can't keep completely relying on
outside agencies for our SRT needs.
2. Recommend creating an Assistant Police
�1 Chief (I'll address my thoughts on that
.. topic in a future presentation).
•Currently
Arlo ¢,e We rely on a Mutual Aid Agreement with
our surrounding agencies for our SRT needs.
•Pocatello Police Department (PPD)
p� •Bannock County Sheriff's Office (BCSO)
1
•Section 11
• "This agreement may be voluntarily
D A H 0 terminated ... not less than thirty (30)
days ..."
Pr
Special Response Team (SRT)
w
I've spoken with the heads of our surrounding Law
� Enforcement agencies.
Chief Schei is open to the possibility of our officers
..�� joining their Immediate Response Unit (IRU)
i
.. His proposal:
0 We get 4 spots on his team
0 $10,000 annually
r
CPD Admin:
t0 Have obtained PPD's IRU policies and are
�1 currently reviewing them
• Realistically
D A H 0 0 We can only fill 2 spots on the team
0 Could possibly renegotiate $5,000 annually?
fj
bVi
ipsnc
Total Per Officer Gear $ 3,978.00
Total Per Officer Training $ 3,700.00
Annual Fee $ 10,000.00
Swat Gear Cost
Cost
Training
Cost
j
Helmut
$1,200.00
swat School
$ 2,000.00
Ear Protection
70.00
Ammo (Yearly)
$1,200.00
Plate Carrier
700.00
SIM Rounds
$ .500.00
Plates (Level VI)
600.00
Swat Belt
Holster
$ 70.00
$ 150.00
Magazine Pouch
$ 140.00
Uniform
$ 180.00
Swat Soft Jacket
170.00
1
Glories
30.00
Boots
150.00
Gas Mask
$ 513.00
Total Per Officer Gear $ 3,978.00
Total Per Officer Training $ 3,700.00
Annual Fee $ 10,000.00
Z
Immediate Response Unit IRU
w1 believe:
�
• Opportunity to receive quality IRU training from a local PD
- with an established team.
• Opportunity for us to "test the waters" to ensure this
relationship will be a good fit.
• way?
Will our members be utilized in a meanin ful
i g
Major Benefit: We will have access to an entire IRU team at
Arlo minimal cost.
I'm requesting:
$25,356
t0 Outfit two CPD Officer for the Team
• Cover the initial $10,000 annual cost to join the team
� Admittedly:
• 1 would be requesting additional funds during the next
budget presentation to maintain our involvement in the
team going forward.
IDAHO
Immediate Response Unit (IRU)
Questions Before Topic Change?
ppppp- 90 C K p
0
Officer Wellness
• Set the Stage
• In his article, Police Departments are Losing Of icers and
Struggling to Replace Them, Kris Maher explains, "A survey
of nearly 200 police departments last year by the Police
Executive Research Forum, a Washington D.C., think tank,
found that the resignation rate per 100 officers was up 18%
between April 2020 and March 2021 compared with the
prior -year period, while the rate of retirements rose 45%"
(Maher, 2022). The article started out by explaining that
smaller agencies aren't immune to this trend and, if you are
paying attention, officers are leaving their jobs for their own
well-being.
• We recently had an officer leave for this exact reason
• In 1995 the Chubbuck Police Department lost Corporal Gregory
Russell Lobdell to suicide.
• Our first responders deal with abnormal things on a normal
basis.
In his book, Bulletproof Spirit, Captain Dan Willis (Ret.) covers a
number of statistics, including the fact that on average 120 — 140
officers commit suicide yearly, 25 — 30% have stress -based health
problems, 40% have serious sleep disorders, 23% seriously abuse
alcohol, etc. (Willis, 2019, p. 23, p. 24, & p. 35). This doesn't even
account for the fact that our junior officers are expected to pick up
more "side duties" than ever before and, because advancements in
social media, they are being scrutinized like no time before.
In this day -and -age, it doesn't take our junior officers long to figure
out that they can make similar money, with half the workload and
scrutiny, doing something else. If senior officers are honest with
themselves, they understand that gone are the days that they can
pretend that as much was expected of them as a younger officer, with
the same level of scrutiny. This profession takes a real toll on our
people and a proactive approach to wellness will keep them healthy
and on the job.
• What's the Point?
• This is a topic that is often spoken about, but a solution is
never acted on.
• We need to start taking our first responders wellness
seriously.
• We need to stop "kicking the can down the road."
• In March of 2022, 1 graduated from the FBINA (class #281)
• 1 attend several 10 -week courses of study
• Advanced Concepts of Wellness and Vitality in Law Enforcement
• I wrote a paper (nothing impressive)
• Proposing a "Wellness Professional" position for the City of
Chubbuck
• This would be costly, but I believe I've found the best
alternative
• Mindbase Platform
• https://getmindbase.comZ
• In the past...
• Application
• Lighthouse
• Lexipol (Cordico)
• The problem with these apps is that nobody access them.
• If they do, we don't know about it.
• Mindbase is different.
• It's much more than an app
• It gives us statistical numbers
• Comparable to our CompStat tool
• Hard Numbers
Mindbase
Platform
App -Based
Wellness
Early Intervention Alerts
Cperatianalized Dashboard
so
w
Proactive Human Connection
am
Personalized Experience
so
Increased Engagement
Activity Tracking
Personalized Self -Care
Anonymized Reporting
Anonymous Wellness Content
Connections to Peer Support
Connections tD Clinical Resources
• Mindbase Cost:
• 3 -year contract
• $5,100 per year
• I'm requesting:
• $15,300 to pay for the entire program for a 3 -year period
• 1 believe:
• This is the a 3 -year contract is a perfect timeframe to
evaluate our planned CPD Wellness Program
• How often its being use?
• What topics are being accessed?
• After 3 -years:
• Re-evaluate and decide if the program is being used to it's
potential
• Admittedly:
• After 3 -years, I would be requesting addition funding in my
budget to maintain the Mindbase tool going forward.
• Last minute addition to presentation
• New Training Room
• Training Mats (24x24)
• Cost: $6,269.40
• Department Logo Included
Questions before I turn it over to our CPD Evidence Expert?
413. -a.
I
9
t
413. -a.
The Evidence Drying Cabinet
An Essential Safety Tool.
AAron R. Harker, MS
Chubbuck Police Department
Evidence Division
What is the purpose of a Drying Cabinet?
• Dries evidence that is
saturated in bodily fluids.
• Control and contain
strong odors of decay,
insects, and airborne
pathogens
• Protects and preserves
evidence.
What happened to current drying cabinet?
• Damaged and
Needs replaced
• Belongs to Bannock
County Sheriff's
office.
0
•
u s
th
Additional Things to Consider
• The replacement cost of unit: $15,848.30
• The filter cost replaced every two years:
• $719 for carbon filters, $405 for Hepa
filters
• $260
• Regula
for 12 p
r ins
IM
refilters (changed each case)
tions of the Drying Cabinet
• For staff safety, the cabinet needs
to be placed in a separate location
from where people work.
• Provides a cleanable and reusable
resource.
• The unit is a standard piece of
41
equipment in a crime lab.
1
l
ANI'
QtiESTIONS
• Water — Following Rate Study
.reserves loans and rate
increases
• Wastewater — Following Rate
Study (reserves, loans and
rate increases)
• Sanitation — to complete a
Rate Stu`&� (may show need to
raise rates
• Streets — Needs which are
funded through dedicated
funds and property taxes.
Streets Department Needs
•Pavement Maintenance
•Equipment
•Projects
Pavement Maintenance (Background)
101
CL
a 80
0 60
40
0
20
E
0
CL
Good
Fair
Poor
Fa
Pavement Age
Resurface
100
Mill
C), 80
a-
70
60
0
#= 50
U 40
30
a
20
10
0
Preventive M&R - Less costly
Range of Typical "Critical PCI" Values
Acceleration of pavement deterioration
Major M&R - More costly
10 20
Pavement Age (Years)
30
Pavement Maintenance (Background)
Proactive vs. Reactive M&R
1001 Original Pavement $1 2 $'7
a Seal Coat
Thin Overlay
75
0 Structural Overlay
50 Remaining Service Life = 0
c Reconstruction
E
a
251
Pavement Age
$15
Pavement Maintenance (LOS and Need)
f [111n
69�7m
90
85
EM
75
MR
65
60
55
50 +_
sta rt
City of Chubbuck, ID
Annual Condition for Various Budget Levels
Analysis Date = 12/30/2021
rrrr—sirrrrrrrrrrr.
Fbc All Budget = $16.2M Over 5 Years
Target PCI = 78, Budget = $1910k/Year
— — Maintain Current Backlog: Final PCI = 75, Backlog = 3%, Annual Budget = $1350k/Yr
r r r Recommended Budget: Final PCI = 74, Backlog= 3°°%, Annual Budget = $1390k/Yr
Chuhhuck Budget: PCI = 69, Backlog = 4%, Annual Budget = $600k/Yr
Steady State PCI: Final PCI = 72, Backlog = 399%, Annual Budget = $1100k/Yr
Backlog Control Budget: PCI = 75, Backlog = 3% Annual Budget = $1350k/Yr
PCI Control Budget: PCI = 75, Backlog = 3°%, Annual Budget = $1390k/Yr
Do Nothing
2021
2022
Year
2023
Chuhhuck has a PCI controlled network
2024
115
To
maintain
overall
PCI, an
estimated
$ 1. 1M per
year is
needed for
asphalt
maint.
5 -YR Plan
4
Legend
— 550K/yr
1.1 M/yr
Y
Z
� T
\ Q
I p
I �
I
c
o W Quinn Rd
0 0.25 0.5 1 Miles
I I I I I I I I =
I J Portneuf
1] Wellness
Complex
1
,
,
,
1
—4483 1 - - -1
% --
,
,
1
Pine RidgeMall
• •
4648 ft Saratoga St O
W Quinn Rd
a
Es PHilikEakagnin, SafeGraph, Ca*oTechnologies, Inc, METI/NASA, USGS, Bureau of Land Management, EPAWVPS,
r US Census Bureau, USDA Esri, NASA, NGA, USGS, FEMA
O
m
Pavement Maintenance (Chubbuck History)
Pavement Maint. and Repair Costs
$2,000,000.00
$1,800,000.00
$1,600,000.00
$1,400,000.00
$1,200,000.00
$1,000,000.00
$800,000.00
$600,000.00
$400,000.00
$200,000.00
2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022
■ Maint. Budget ■ CDA Contribution
2023 Pavement Maintenance
• Approximately 1 mile of mill
and overlay
• $426,000
• $500,000 total pavement
maintenance related cost
Budget Highlights
• Budget includes
$275,000 for new
sweeper and small
snow plow in
accordance with
Capital Equipment
Plan.
• Budget includes
$404,400 for Pavement
Maintenance to result
in a balanced budget
(expenses=revenue)
• Pavement
Management Plan
shows a need for a
minimum of $ I . IM per
year on pavement
maintenance to
maintain current
pavement conditions.
• Identified need of
$695,600 to meet
pavement management
plan.
Budget Request Summary
FY23 Final Budget
FY24 Proposed Budget
$$$ Change
% Change
ESTIMATED Revenue
$2,300,000.00
$2,474,000.00
$174,000.00
7.6%
Wages & Benefits
$778,700.00
$887,500.00
$108,800.00
13.97%
Administration
$276,200.00
$305,800.00
$29,600.00
10.72%
z
Operational Expenses (including Capital
Equip. and Pavement Maint.)
$1,109,100.00
$1,144,700.00
$35,600.00
3.21%
W
5
Additional Services
$0.00
$0.00
$0.00
Debt Service
$136,000.00
$136,000.00
$0.00
0.00%
a
W
Q
Total Planned Expenses
$2,300,000.00
$2,474,000.00
$174,000.00
7.6%
oc
Capital Equipment (included in Operational
Expenses above)
$0.00
$275,000.00
$275,000.00
Pavement Maintenance (included in
Operational Expenses above)
$547,400.00
$404,400.00
-$143,000.00
Expenses Exceeding Revenue
$0.00
$0.00
$0.00
Identified Additional Needs
$695,600.00
Budget Highlights
• Budget includes
$275,000 for new
sweeper and small
snow plow in
accordance with
Capital Equipment
Plan.
• Budget includes
$404,400 for Pavement
Maintenance to result
in a balanced budget
(expenses=revenue)
• Pavement
Management Plan
shows a need for a
minimum of $ I . IM per
year on pavement
maintenance to
maintain current
pavement conditions.
• Identified need of
$695,600 to meet
pavement management
plan.
Revenue Uncertainty
• FY23 — Budgeted Revenue $2.3M
• FY23
$2,500,000.00
$2,000,000.00
$1,500,000.00
$1,000,000.00
$500,000,00
Actual Revenue $1,941,487
FY22 Total
FY23 Total
U309,49i
Capital Projects Request Summary
a to rn
FY23
FY24
FY25
FY26
FY27
Pavement Management
$ 547,400.00
404,400.00
$ 675,000.00
$ 400,000.00
675,000.00
Chubbuck Roundabout - 1-15 Crossing (ITD
Funded)
Siphon - New Day/ Yellowstone Intersection
LU
CDA Potenial Projects (Council Agreement)
Total
$ 547,400.00
$ 404,400.00
675,000.00
400,000.00
$ 675,000.00
Identified Additional Needs
CL
W
Pavement Management
$ 695,600.00
$ 425,000.00
w 700,000,00
$ 425,000,00
2
Total
-
$ 695,600,00
S 425,00€1.00
700,000.00
425,000.00
Total
$ 547,400.00
$ 1,1 0,000.00
;} 1,1DI'OU0.00
5 1,100'.000.00
1,100,000.()0
Streets Department Needs
•pavPmant I.vlq I
•Equipment
•YrrnPctc
MZ��
Capital Equipment Summary
Item
FY23
FY24
FY25
FY26
FY27
Snow Plow Truck
$75,000,00
$50,000.00
$75,000.00
Street Sweeper
$0.00
w2 215, C 0().00
SO.00
$250,000.00
z
W
Striping Grinder
w0.o0
Asphalt Roller
$45,000.00
CL
Total
$75,000,00
X275.000.00
S0.00
S37C1,OU0.00
S
Uj
Source of Funds
Operations Budget
'75,008.00
Sweeper Grants
Total
$75,000,00
$0.00
$0.00
S0.1:10
w -
Total
$0.00
-$275,000.00
$0.00
S
Equipment Needs
• Capital Equipment Plan (snow plows,
street sweepers, rollers)
Additional Equipment needs
• Mastic Machine — to allow our crews to
f$70k)m some of the asphalt maintenance
• Equipment for weed control — 4 -wheelers,
(40
�ra
k) rs, steam machine, trimmers, etc.
Streets Department Needs
•Pavement iviLain
•Equipmen`
•Projects
Projects
• Hawthorne Road Bridge ($1.5-$2M)
• Match for ITD project — Yellowstone/Siphon
intersection (portion of signal, sidewalks and
paths, landscaping, etc.)
r