The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About010 01 81LAND USE & DEVELOPMENT CC~MISSION MINUTES October 1, 1981 Minutes of the regular meeting of the Land Use & development Conmission held in the City ~kmicipal Building, October 1, 1981. Present: Chairman Richard Allen, Co~mission _.Members: Dee Stalder, Pete Anderson, Earl Romriell, Myrna Cain, Janet Williams, City Engineer Steven Smart, Secretary Dorothy Ward, Chairman Allen welcomed Robert Allen as a new Commission Member. Meeting called to order at 8:00 p.m. by ChairmanAllen. ChainnanAllen asked for any corrections or additions to the minutes of September 10, 1981; there being none, Dee Stalder made the motion to accept minutes as written. Pete Anderson seconded the motion, with all Ccmmzission~rs voting in favor. PUBLIC HEARING ITEM: GEORGE A. STEINMETZ FOR A CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT FOR A TRANSMISSION REPAIR SHOP at 4959 Hawthorne. Mr. Steinmetz said he worked on transmissions out of cars, mostly for Shaw Auto Parts. He said occasionally he had a vehicle in for repairs, however he had all the facilities to do any type of car repair. Chairman Allen asked Mr, Steienmetz if this was a full time operation. He replied yes, it is their source of income. Janet Williams asked if he expected to erect a sign. He replied, no, he did not need a sign, he has all the work he could do. Chairman Allen asked for public testimony in favor of the Transmission Repair Shop. LindaLarsen, 4950 Hawthorne Road, said she and her husband did not object to the shop in the neighborhood. Chairman Allen read a statement from some of the immediate neighbors stating they found it not tobe an annoyance to them. This statement attached to the minutes. There being no other testimony in favor, Chairman Allen asked for testimony opposed to the Transmission Repair Shop. Bob Ward, 4930 Hawthorne Road, requested Hawthorne Road be re-zoned Comnercial if the Commission continues to allow conn~rcial uses to go in, such as the Transmission Repair Shop. He stated there are several areas that could be utilized for just such uses. He asked the Commission if they did allow the Transmission Repair Shop to go in, to make strict conditions and asked if it could be reviewed each year. PUBLIC~ HEARING - GEORGE A. STE12qME~Z - continued Chairman Allen then closed the public testimony. Chairman Allen then read frcmOrdinance # 205 the definition of vehicle repair. He stated this request should perhaps be handled as a home occupation. - The Commission then discussed the possibilities of this request as a home occupation and if a vehicle repair shop wouldbe allowed. Earl Romriell questioned if this could be classified as a hc~e occupation. Dee Stalder said the city has the Land Use Ordinance and he felt it should be upheld, that a vehicle repair shop was not allowed in an R-2 zone. Pete Anderson questioned Mr. Steinmetz as to the other work he did, not related to transmission repair and the parking. Mr. Steinmetz said he possibly worked on two cars a week that he always had them parked inside of the shop and never parked cars in the street. Pete Andersonmade motion to consider the request of George A. Steinmetz as a home occupation. ~;rna Cain seconded themotion. Stalder, no; RDmreill, abstained, Anderson, yes; Robert Allen, yes; Richard Allen, yes; Cain, yes and Williams, yes. Janet Williams made motion to recc~mend to the City Council for approval subject to the following conditions: shop be used for transmission repair only, size of building not to exceed twenty five (25) percent of the dwelling size, no exterior storage, no exterior signs, operating hours be from 8:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m., vehicles to be repaired be in enclosed area, that all expansion to be brought before the Con~nission, for Mr. Steinmetz to meet the standards set forth in Ordinance #205 regarding home occupation and the conditions not transferable. Pete Anderson seconded the motion. Stalder, no; Romriell, abstained; Robert Allen, yes; Richard Allen, yes; Anderson, yes, Cain, yes; Williams, yes. OTHER BUSINESS: Design Review - Pine Ridge Chevron Sign. The Con~ssion reviewed the application and photograph of the sign. Earl Romriell made motion to re~d to the City Council for approval the sign of the Pine Ridge Chevron. Dee Stalder seconded themotion, with all voting in favor. Design Review - North Chuckwagon Restaurant to be built at the Pine Ridge Mall. The Commission reviewed the plans and discussed the area with the City Engineer, Steven Smart. Earl Romriell made motion to reccmm~_nd for approval the Design Review of the North Chuckwagon to the City Council. Janet Williams seconded themotion. With all Co~mission~rs voting in favor. OTHER BUSINESS: Design Review - addition to McArthurMachine Shop - 342 Hiway Avenue. Steven Smart said application was not complete, therefore he was unable to make any recon~nendations. Pete Anderson mademotion to table the Design Review application of McArthur ~chine shop until conrplete drawings are brought in and the application completed. MyrnaCain seconded the motion, with all Commission Meml~rs voting in favor. Dee Staldermade motion to adjOurn at 9:50 p.m., Janet Williams seconded themotion. All members voted in favor. Dorothy 1. ~ard, Secretary We the neighbors of A1 Steinmetz understand that he is operating a business at his home and we also agree that there is no annoyance in him doing so. Thankyou . Name of Applicant: NORTH CHUCK WAGON Subject of Application: DESIGN REVIEW - PINE RIDGE MAIL CITY OF CHUBBUCK ACTION SUMMARY LAND USE AND DEVELOPMENT COMMISSION A. NATURE OF ACTION: /Recommendation to City Council Decision (Subject to Appeal to City Council) B. ACTION TAKEN: Application Approved Application Denied Application Approved on Following Condition(s): C. SOURCES CONSIDERED: Chubbuck Comprehensive Plan (with any applicable ndments) Chubbuck Land Use Ordinance (with any applicable amendments) JO&ubbuck Land Development Ordinance (with any applicable amendments) Chubbuck Land Improvement Standards Ordinance (with any applicable amendments) Other: D. REASONS FOR ACTICN TAKEN: E. ACTIONS APPLICANT COULD TAKE TO OBTAIN FAVORABLE' CONSIDERATION: A Not Applicable Application not Denied) Applicable: This summary supplements the official minutes of a meeting/hearing on this date, el -IN and constitutes part of the record of Commission act' n the above matter. Date airman ding Officer n n A. NATURE OF ACTION: B. ACTIN TAKEN: Name of Applicant: ,ec)rqp A _ Sf ai nn otg Subject of Application: C ONDTTW TAT. TTSF pPDMTT p= A TRANSMISSION REPAIR SHOP AT 4954 Hawthorne Road CITY OF CHUBBUCK ACTION SUMMARY LAND USE AND DEVELOPMENT COMMISSION Recommendation to City Council L, Decision (Subject to Appeal to City Council) ,./Application Approved Application Denied Application Approved on Following Condition(s): Shop be used for transmission repair only, size of building not to exceed 25% (Sbdifto awel:-L±M size, no rror storage, no error signs, operating hours br from 8:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m., vechicles to be repaired be in enclosed area, that ug ore a ommrssron, for Mr. Steinmetz to meet the standards set forth in Ordinance #205 regarding home occupation and the con . C. SOURCES CONSIDERED: Chubbuck Comprehensive Plan (with any applicable amendments) Chubbuck Land Use Ordinance (with any applicable amendments) Chubbuck Land Development Ordinance (with any applicable amendments) Chubbuck Land Improvement Standards Ordinance (with any applicable amendments) Other: D REASONS FOR ACTION TAKEN: E. ACTIONS APPLICANT COULD TAKE TO OB'T'AIN FAVORABLE CONSIDERATION: Not Applicable (Application not Denied) Applicable: This summary supplements the official minutes of a and constitutes part of the record of Commission Date ing on this date, above matter. n Subject of Application: nFSTGN REVIEW - SIGN CITY OF CHUBBUCK ACTION SUMMARY LAND USE AMID DEVELOPMENT COMMISSION A. NATURE OF ACTION: Recorrmendation to City Council Decision (Subject to Appeal to City Council) B. ACTION TAKEN: L. -,Application Approved Application Denied Application Approved on Following Condition(s): C. SOURCES CONSIDERED: Chubbuck Comprehensive Plan (with any applicable amendments) Chubbuck Land Use Ordinance (with any applicable amendments) Chubbuck Land Development Ordinance (with any applicable amendments) Chubbuck Land Improvement Standards Ordinance (with any applicable amendments) Other: �/Gji% G�C�/�7Q� �•� D. REASONS FOR ACTION TAKEN: E. ACTIONS APPLICANT COULD TAKE TO OBTAIN FAVORABLE CONSIDERATION: Not Applicable (Application not Denied) Applicable: This summary supplements the official minutes of a meetingAearinq on this date, and constitutes part of the record of Comniss: /'q --- / - �l