HomeMy WebLinkAbout003 06 80LAND USE & LAND DEVELOPMENT COMMISSION MINUTES
March 6, 1980
Minutes of the regular meeting of the Land Use & Land Development Commission
held in the city municipal building, March 6, 1980.
Meeting called to order at 8:40 p.m. by Chairman Dee Stalder.
Present: Chairman Stalder, Commission Members: Dell Peters, Mike Metcalfe,
Richard Allen and Becky Hopkins. City Engineer, Steven Smart and Secretary
Dorothy Ward. Janet Williams, Myrna Cain and Dean Wood were excused.
Chairman Stalder asked for any corrections or additions to the minutes of
meeting held February 7, 1980, there being none, Dell Peters made motion to
accept minutes as written. Mike Metcalfe seconded the motion. All voted in
favor.
PUBLIC HEARING: 1. WHETHER THE CHUBBUCK LAND USE ORDINANCE, NO. 205 should
be amended . The Commission discussed if Government Facilities should have been
included in the shedule of General Controls.
Mike Metcalfe made motion to recommend to the City Council that Ordinance
No. 205 be amended to include in schedule of General Controls 2-3 (b) the
addition of "Government Facilities" with following controls:
A R-1 R-2 C-1 C-2 I
P X X X P P
Dell Peters seconded the motion. The voting was unanimous in favor. B: Fences
The placement of fences which obscure vision was.discussed by the Commission.
Engineer Smart reported there was confusion in the office on the interpetation
of the fence ordinance and felt it should be more specific. He then detailed
it out on the blackboard for the commission to be able to see and to get their
opinion.
Mike ~letcalfe made motion to recommend to the City Council Ordinance No. 205,
Section 3-5, Paragraph (f) be amended to read: No structure, fence, object
or vegetation shall be constructed, placed or allowed to grow or permitted to
remain at any location where it materially obscures "Line-of-sight Vision",
from a street or vehicular way to any point within fifteen (15) feet of
point of intersection of back out driveway and right of way on either side of
driveway or to any point within fifteen (15) feet along an intersecting street
or vehicular way.
Richard Allen seconded the motion. Voting was unanimous in favor.
C: Variances
Becky Hopkins said she would like to have a time limit and conditions for
variances granted within the city.
Chairman Stalder reminded the Commission that reasonable conditions could
be asked for on variances and if the City deviates it should be able to set
conditions.
VARIANCE - contue'd
Dell Peters said statement should be conducive under the conditions variance
is granted.
Richard Allen made motion to recommend to the City Council Item C of the
public hearing be amended to read: The City may place limitations on the
duration of variance granted or otherwise each variance subject to yearly review
and the City may impose conditions ( including requirements not otherwise set
forth in the Ordinance) for the granting of variances.
Dell Peters seconded the motion. All voted in favor.
D. Accessory Structures
Engineer Smart said it had been suggested to him the limiting of the amount of
lot that can be covered with accessory structures; he said it would be
possible for some one to build an accessory structure that Would eliminate a
yard.
Richard Allen suggested a limitation be put on height and per cent of coverage
of the lot.
Discussion followed on the height that should be allowed on an accessory
structure and the percentage of lot[ that can be covered.
Mike Metcalfe made motion to recommend to the City Council that Ordinance #205
be amended, Section 3-4, Paragraph (a) Accessory Structures --a sub-paragraph
(3) be added to read: May not be in excess of ten feet (10') in height at
eaves and maximum height of sixteen feet (16').
Sub-paragraph (4) May not cover in excess of ten percent (10%) of rear yard
or portion of side yard beside or behind principal structure.
Richard Allen seconded the motion. All voted in favor.
2. VIHETHER THE LAND DEVELOPMENT ORDINANCES # 206 should be amended.
A. Final Design Drawings
Engineer Smart reviewed with the Commission pages 9 and 13 of Ordinance #206.
He said the p~iminary phase essentially in the wording of the ordinance has
the developer~U~ engineers completely design the water and sewer systems as a
major part of design in a sub division and at a large expense and they do not
need to do it. He recommended it be changed in the preliminary plat so they
would have to present only preliminary drawings showing locations and etc., he
also said several areas should be changed in the wording.
Dell Peters asked why the Engineer w~ntedthe developer to submit the plans
as he had suggested. Mr. Smart said if they were required to submit all
the final drawings at the preliminary plat stage it is far to expensive, as
sometimes they are just checking into a development.
FINAL DESIGN DRAWINGS, CONTINUED
Richard Allen~ade motion to recommend to the City Council the Land Development
Ordinance No. 206 should be ammended to read: Section 2-~
E. Proposed Utility Methods
1. Sewage Disposal- Preliminary location and carrying capacity of
all lines or conduits and necessary appurtenances.
2. Water Supply: Preliminary location and carrying capacity of all
lines or conduits and necessary appurtenances.
Section 2-6, add a new paragraph, page 13:
H. Documents Required
1. Sewage Disposal: Design location and carrying capacity of all
lines or conduits and appurtenances, together with a evidence that the
developer has furnished the State of Idaho, Division of Environment, such
information as the Division may require regarding design and operation of
sanitary sewage facilities.
2. Water Supply- Design location and carrying capacity of all
lines or conduits and appurtenances, together with a letter from said
Division approving proposed water volume and quantity.
3. Streets: Design location of all streets including curb,
gutter and sidewalk and pavement.
4. Storm Water Design Disposal: Design calculations and layout
of disposal system and location of outlets.
5. Other Utilities: Layout of gas lines, electrical lines,
television cables, telephone lines and other utilities.
Mike Metcalfe seconded the motion. Voting was unanimous in favor.
B. Cash Contributions in lien of parks.
Richard Allen suggested the cash contribution should be for the finished
products rather than the bare ground. He explained it was a considerable
expense to the City to develop bare ground into parks.
Engineer Smart said the ordinance now states the developer donate land at
his cost, plus value of curb, gutter and sidewalk; but if those were
developed lots, like the remainder of the subdivision the lots would be
worth considerable more.
Dell Peters said it would raise the cost to developers but it would enhance
the remainder of the subdivision, and this cost is passed on to the buyers.
Richard Allen made motion to recommend to the City Council the following
amendment to the Land Development Ordinance #206: The cash contributions
in lieu of land dedicated by developers for parks and recreation purposes
the "fair market value' of the land shall be computed to include the enhancement
of value created by the remainder of the development and also to include the
cost of improvements that would otherwise be required under Section 3-3 (E)
Cash Contribuions in Lieu of Parks, continued
(5),if such dedication occurs.
in favor.
Dell Peters seconded the motion. All voted
3. TO CONSIDER A PROPOSED AMENDMENT TO OR SUBSTITUTION FOR CHUBBUCK
ORDINANCE No. 177.
The Commission discussed if another ordinance should be drafted - the impact
area and the administration of the Ordinance.
Engineer Smart showed a draft ordinance that he and the County.have been
working on. He said there were several areas that had to be worked out.
1. To draft an ordinance.
2. Impact area.
3. Ordinance administration.
4. Chubbuck City Impact Area Development Commission.
Dell Peters asked if City of Pocatello is acting on same ordinance. The
Commission was reminded Impact Area might be city limits some day, also
discussed area Pocatello would like to see withdrawn from Chubbuck Impact
Area.
Dell Peters made motion to table this item, on Ordinance No. 177, until the
April 3, 1980 meeting. Richard Allen seconded the motion. Voting was
unanimous in favor.
Mike Metcalfe made motion to adjourn at 10:20 p.m. Dell Peters seconded the
motion. All voted in favor.
o othy L. Wa~ Secretary
H. Dee Stalder, Chairman